[RCC] - Help with Rosetta Nebula Requests for constructive critique · Glenn Silverman · ... · 9 · 349 · 0

glancey 0.00
...
· 
Need help processing Rosetta Nebula taken with my new ZWO ASI2600MC Pro with an Optolong L-Enhance filter from a Bottle 7 site. The image is an integration of 35, 5-min subs, with darks, flats and bias frames.  Its been run through Pixinsight with curve and multiple dynamic background transformations. Nevertheless, I can't seem to make a dent on removing the bluish background gradient. I've even tried removing the gradient from both star and starless images after applying StarXTerminator. Is it hopeless, or is there anything I can try to at least reduce the background artifacts? There's also a redish glow in the central area of the image, which I believe is part of the larger NGC2237 DSO. But I can't seem to bring out any of the nebulosity there either. Any suggestions from experts here are appreciated.

https://astrob.in/txgoc8/0/
Like
messierman3000 4.20
...
· 
Try increasing the Tolerance (in model parameters 1) to at least 2 in DBE. I noticed it works more aggressively. Also make sure to put enough Samples all around the nebulosity.
Like
leviathan 4.72
...
· 
·  1 like
Glenn, I downloaded your JPEG file and cropped it using DynamicCrop in order to get rid of the darkened corners, then used DBE with tolerance 2 and samples of 100-200 and image now looks much better.
Like
jml79 3.87
...
· 
Use an image editing program, mask the rosette and use a curve to reduce the blue channel. PI is good but it isn’t the best tool for everything.
Like
glancey 0.00
...
· 
Try increasing the Tolerance (in model parameters 1) to at least 2 in DBE. I noticed it works more aggressively. Also make sure to put enough Samples all around the nebulosity.

Your suggestion worked! Thanks,

Glenn
Like
messierman3000 4.20
...
· 
@Glenn Silverman No problem.
I had only 3-4 days of Pixinsight experience, and it was only by luck that I discovered the Tolerance thing (it helped to remove complex gradients on my images too).

CS
messierman3000
Like
glancey 0.00
...
· 
@Glenn Silverman No problem.
I had only 3-4 days of Pixinsight experience, and it was only by luck that I discovered the Tolerance thing (it helped to remove complex gradients on my images too).

CS
messierman3000

I works like a charm.  Thanks for the tip.

Glenn
Like
glancey 0.00
...
· 
Now, if I only knew how to reduce the number of stars.

Glenn
Like
jml79 3.87
...
· 
·  1 like
Starnet++.
Like
pil0t1 0.00
...
· 
Something is off in your setup; I had the same setup (2600mc, l-enhance, Redcat 51v2) and shot almost the same frame just last month; the dark band on the right side of the image shouldn't be there. Can you share your light/flat frames (dark/bias doesn't matter much with that camera)? I bet there is something off in your imaging train. 

Let's assume calibration frames are done right and your imaging train is all in good shape. What I would suggest is to use `dynamic background extraction` with about 60ish points making sure none falls over any star or nebulosity, and see the result. You can play with tolerance and see if that helps, but again, I found it more important to have all samples on the background, not stars.


Here is the star reduction script I use, along with the youtube link

https://www.amazon.ca/clouddrive/share/t37K5QLnJq5H7yU9fJq6gpmc8oe823hM0snoi9WUa4J
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4rhvHEBmjcM
Edited ...
Like
 
Register or login to create to post a reply.